Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Field Reading

I’ve spent the past year reading like an extractive industry: mining books and articles for theoretical nuggets that I could summarize in one or two sentences for my preliminary exams or the literature reviews in my grant applications. This is not a satisfying way to read -- it’s a survival strategy.

In the final weeks building up to my exams, I fantasized about the day I would pick up a book and read for pleasure. It’s been several years since I’ve really read for the joy of reading. Even when I’ve been fortunate enough to read research-related books that were beautifully crafted and gripping, I was too often doing so on deadline, and in typical grad student fashion: read the introduction and conclusion, skim other chapters for ethnographic evidence -- and do so as quickly as possible.

My friends have been helping me recover the pleasure of reading. Stacey cajoled me into reading the ultimate historical junk book: Pillars of the Earth -- 983 pages that veer between 12th-century soap opera and Gothic cathedral-building tutorial. Kathleen refreshed my love of Barbara Kingsolver with The Poisonwood Bible, and Jen gave me Blindness by José Saramago as a post-prelim present. I’ll open it tonight for the first time.

I’m in an academic discipline that values good writing, a discipline that is most powerful when its members combine rigorous scholarship and theoretical insight with richly textured ethnographies. Once upon a time I loved to write, particularly poetry. But this phase of graduate school has left me speaking and writing in jargon. Most of the time I don’t even realize it’s jargon until my family asks for a translation. Over the next 15 months I’ll be taking field notes on a daily basis with the goal of writing my dissertation next year, and one day, si Dios quiere, my own book.

So here’s my goal: To spend the next 15 months in the field reading books that that will not only be enjoyable to read, but that will also help me to be a better writer. I want to read authors who will help me listen to the cadence of dialogue, and who will help me think about character development and how to vividly set a scene. I also just want to read gripping stories. For fun.

Daunted by the idea of lugging 100 books to Bolivia with me, I recently bought a Kindle (e-reader). I’ve been filling it up ever since. And I want to ask my cohortmates and the blogosphere what you-all will be reading this summer, what you are planning to read in the field, and what you think I should read while I’m in Bolivia.

Basically, I want to start a discussion thread on good books.

All genres are welcome, from science fiction to the realism of Depression-era literature. And I would especially love to hear about powerfully written ethnographies. I’ll list below books I’m lining-up for the field. I’d love to hear what you are reading or what you think I should add to my reading list.

My Working List
Germinal, Émile Zola
A Tale of Two Cities, Charles Dickens
Bleak House, Charles Dickens
Oliver Twist, Charles Dickens
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Stieg Larsson
The Death of Ivan Ilych, Leo Tolstoy
The Plague of Doves, Louise Erdrich
The Painted Drum, Louise Erdrich
The Lacuna, Barbara Kingsolver
A Mercy, Toni Morrison
Cutting for Stone, Abraham Verhgese

And of course, a few anthropologists…
Prisoners of Freedom: Human Rights and the African Poor, Harri Englund
Markets of Dispossession: NGOs, Economic Development, and the State in Cairo, Julia Elyachar
Liquidated: An Ethnography of Wall Street, Karen Ho
The Palm at the End of the Mind: Relatedness, Religiosity, and the Real, Michael Jackson

9 comments:

Stacey said...

A post after my own heart!

I'm faced with the same dilemma and don't know where to start myself, but thought I'd offer up this recent Jezebel list instead for now:

http://jezebel.com/5596808/10-not+trashy-but-totally-entertaining-beach-reads/gallery/

Andrea said...

A few pop into mind:

1. The Cairo Trilogy by Naguib Mahfouz. Awesome. He won the Nobel for literature. Read it for a post-colonial anthro class in college that morphed into Reading Rainbow when we all presented on fiction books we loved that were on colonialiam/post-colonialism. Sadly, LeVar Burton wasn't there.

2. A Golden Age, Tahmima Anam. Fiction book about Bangladesh independence. Coincidentally, written by my TA for the aforementioned class. So, score one for anthropologists.

3. The Glass Palace, Amitav Ghosh. Another anthropologist turned writer. Another colonial/post-colonial book. One of my favs.

4. P.G. Wodehouse. Comic writer, books set in Edwardian England. Famous for the the Jeeves and Wooster series, which follows a butler and his silly boss. In my mind, one of the best comic writers.

5. Some things on my list: Luke suggested Alice Munro short stories, so I bought some. I also plan to read Murder on the Orient Express by good old Agatha Christie, In the Kitchen, Wallander mysteries by Henning Mankell. I like mysteries. Note: I brough along all these "important books" to read. Stalling on the Prison Notebooks, as after a long day of interviews, thinking about hegemony is less attractive than Top Chef...

Susan said...

Andrea, Did you know LeVar Burton was my first crush?

True Story.

These suggestions look great! I am headed to amazon.com right now...

Stacey said...

And while we're at it, has everyone signed up for Amazon Prime Student? It will even reimburse your membership fees if you've already enrolled!

http://www.amazon.com/gp/student/signup/info

Andrea said...

Susan, LeVar on the Enterprise, as book promoter, or as Kunta Kinte? Which reminds me I've always wanted to read Roots.

One more book. The completely trashy American Wife. Loosely based on Laura Bush's life. Delightful plane reading.

Sohini said...

Anything by Amitav Ghosh (also trained as an anthropologist). Andrea mentioned Glass Palace, but also highly recommend The Hungry Tide (check out the acknowledgements - shout out to Brown anthro dissertation) or The Sea of Poppies.

Susan said...

Alas, Amitav Ghosh is not Kindle-friendly.

Perhaps he's an author worthy of the suitcase space, though. I will take a few real books with me to the field...

Andrea, the answer to your question is: Reading Rainbow days, though my heart followed him to the Next Generation. I was born the year Roots (the miniseries) came out...

Andrea said...

Susan, being born the year Roots came out is no excuse. I mean I was born post-Jeffersons, but that doesn't mean as an impressionable 8 year old who attended the summer camp of day-time tv, I clicked past George and Wheezy.

I guess it is understandable, but it is LeVar's big break.

Anonymous said...

The prince of tides is one of my all time favorites. I'm not sure that your family is Southern crazy enough to get the full force of the book, but even if ya'll are a little Southern crazy, that should do. Also the writing is just beautiful. Hope all is well in el alto and that you aren't too cold, bless your heart. Hugs, e